Logo
Search
Baseball Replay
LOG IN
SIGN UP
HOME
ARCHIVE
TAGS
ABOUT

Epic Performances

Unbelievable feats, historic games, and unforgettable moments

All Posts

Mets’ First Cycle Belongs to Jim Hickman

Epic Performances

/

Sep 27, 2025

Mets’ First Cycle Belongs to Jim Hickman

On August 7, 1963, he did it in the rarest way possible—naturally

Iron Man in Relief: Lindy McDaniel Saves the Yankees

Epic Performances

/

Sep 23, 2025

Iron Man in Relief: Lindy McDaniel Saves the Yankees

A 13-inning gem out of the bullpen lifts New York past Detroit in extra innings

Bench Belts Three Homers Off Carlton in One Game

Epic Performances

/

Sep 22, 2025

Bench Belts Three Homers Off Carlton in One Game

Reds catcher drives in 7 with a legendary performance against future Hall of Fame left-hander

Phillies Bury Cubs in Epic First Inning

Epic Performances

/

Sep 21, 2025

Phillies Bury Cubs in Epic First Inning

Phillies wasted no time lighting up the scoreboard against Chicago

15 Innings, No Hits: Walker’s Texas League Gem

Epic Performances

/

Sep 20, 2025

15 Innings, No Hits: Walker’s Texas League Gem

Dallas pitcher Tommy Walker makes history with one of baseball’s longest no-hitters

Buehrle’s Perfect Run: High Hopes to Heartbreak

Epic Performances

/

Sep 17, 2025

Buehrle’s Perfect Run: High Hopes to Heartbreak

Mark Buehrle’s historic streak had fans dreaming of back-to-back perfection

In Case of Emergency, Use Stairs

Epic Performances

/

Sep 16, 2025

In Case of Emergency, Use Stairs

Matt Stairs sets all-time pinch-hit home run record in 2010

When a Yankees Pitcher Became the Slugger

Epic Performances

/

Sep 12, 2025

When a Yankees Pitcher Became the Slugger

Vic Raschi’s bat made as much noise as his arm in a record-setting 1953 rout

When the Reds Couldn’t Stop Hitting

Epic Performances

/

Sep 7, 2025

When the Reds Couldn’t Stop Hitting

Cincinnati’s stunning 14-run first inning against Houston in1989

Paul Molitor Steals the Show—Literally

Epic Performances

/

Aug 30, 2025

Paul Molitor Steals the Show—Literally

Brewers star swipes second, third, and home in a single inning to spark a win over Oakland

Nolan Ryan at 45: Still Mowing Them Down

Epic Performances

/

Aug 23, 2025

Nolan Ryan at 45: Still Mowing Them Down

At 45, Ryan extends his own record with milestone performance

Gladden’s 9th-Inning Blast Caps Incredible Three-Game Streak

Epic Performances

/

Aug 20, 2025

Gladden’s 9th-Inning Blast Caps Incredible Three-Game Streak

Three games back from the DL, three game-winning hits

Bill Mueller’s Historic Power Show: Two Grand Slams, Two Sides of the Plate

Epic Performances

/

Aug 16, 2025

Bill Mueller’s Historic Power Show: Two Grand Slams, Two Sides of the Plate

Red Sox switch-hitter made his own unique place in an already exclusive club

Vada Pinson’s Daring Dash Stuns Braves - and Teammates

Epic Performances

/

Aug 15, 2025

Vada Pinson’s Daring Dash Stuns Braves - and Teammates

Reds Star Steals Home in the 9th to Preserve First-Place Lead Over Dodgers

Rookie Kerry Wood's Masterpiece

Epic Performances

/

Aug 13, 2025

Rookie Kerry Wood's Masterpiece

In just his fifth MLB start, the Cubs rookie was matching the greats

Rookie Shatters 101-Year-Old Record

Epic Performances

/

Aug 10, 2025

Rookie Shatters 101-Year-Old Record

A's newbie starts career with scoreless streak not seen in a century

Rookie Reliever’s Dream Moment

Epic Performances

/

Aug 9, 2025

Rookie Reliever’s Dream Moment

Detroit rookie Daryl Patterson faces the fire—and fans the Orioles

Saving Perfection for Buehrle

Epic Performances

/

Aug 8, 2025

Saving Perfection for Buehrle

Mark Buehrle’s perfect game nearly vanished—until DeWayne Wise took flight.

33 Up, 33 Down: Montague’s Hidden Gem in 1977

Epic Performances

/

Aug 6, 2025

33 Up, 33 Down: Montague’s Hidden Gem in 1977

Seattle reliever quietly matched perfection — over two games.

Daring Dash Stunned the Dodgers

Epic Performances

/

Aug 4, 2025

Daring Dash Stunned the Dodgers

Tommie Agee steals the show—and home—in a 10th-inning thriller at Dodger Stadium

“Miracle Man” Arrives: Marichal’s Magical Debut

Epic Performances

/

Aug 1, 2025

“Miracle Man” Arrives: Marichal’s Magical Debut

22-year-old call-up dazzles with near-perfect game

Willie Mays at 37: Still Running Wild

Epic Performances

/

Jul 28, 2025

Willie Mays at 37: Still Running Wild

The Say Hey Kid scores the difference-maker in vintage style

Marathon on the Mound

Epic Performances

/

Jul 27, 2025

Marathon on the Mound

Pirates starter nearly goes the distance in a 19-inning thriller vs. the Braves

Hank Aaron steals home in wild birthday game for Joe Torre

Epic Performances

/

Jul 20, 2025

Hank Aaron steals home in wild birthday game for Joe Torre

Braves pulled off a double steal and a rare triple steal in one inning

Triple play stuns, A-Rod debuts and Fenway roars

Epic Performances

/

Jul 16, 2025

Triple play stuns, A-Rod debuts and Fenway roars

'94 Mariners-Red Sox showdown gave fans plenty to cheer

Load more

Baseball Replay

Relive the moments that shaped your love for the game, through the eyes of the journalists who covered them

© 2025 Replay Press.

Privacy policy

Terms of use

Powered by beehiiv